top of page

What Are the Consequences of Unfounded Product Claims?

The race to capture consumer attention and loyalty can be relentless. Brands invest massive resources into product development, marketing, and advertising to stand out in the crowded marketplace. However, a critical aspect of this pursuit is often underestimated or overlooked—the credibility and integrity of your brand’s product claims. Unfounded or misleading product claims can have severe consequences, not only for your brand's legal standing and reputation but also for your bottom line. We’ll unpack the potential ramifications of making unfounded product claims and explore why brands should prioritize accuracy and transparency in their messaging.

1. Damage to Brand Reputation

One of the most immediate and detrimental consequences of unfounded product claims is the erosion of brand reputation. When consumers discover that a brand's promises do not align with reality, trust is shattered and you’ll likely have many disappointed customers on your hands. Negative reviews, social media backlash, and word-of-mouth warnings can spread like wildfire, tarnishing your brand's image.


A damaged reputation can be extremely difficult to recover from. It may take years of consistent, honest marketing and product quality improvements to rebuild the trust that was lost due to unfounded claims. This can mean huge losses in revenue and major reinvestments in the meantime, which can often spell the end for ill-equipped brands (especially smaller companies!)

2. Legal and Regulatory Consequences

Making false or unsubstantiated product claims can lead to legal and regulatory issues. Regulatory bodies, such as the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in the United States, are vigilant in monitoring and penalizing deceptive advertising practices. Their requirements specifically prohibit claims that mislead consumers. Further, they now insist on all product claims being substantiated with some form of research (such as a clinical trial or a consumer perception study.)


Fines, lawsuits, and costly legal battles can drain a brand's resources and damage its financial stability. Additionally, regulatory actions can result in mandatory product recalls, further harming your brand's reputation and finances.

3. Loss of Consumer Trust and Loyalty

Unfounded product claims can cause consumers to lose trust in your brand. In an era where consumers have access to vast amounts of information and product reviews, they are quick to discern when a claim lacks substance.


Loss of trust leads to diminished brand loyalty. Consumers are more likely to seek alternatives from brands they perceive as more transparent and honest. The long-term financial impact of losing loyal customers can be significant.

4. Reduced Sales and Revenue

Ultimately, unfounded product claims can result in reduced sales and revenue. When consumers feel misled or simply don’t have enough evidence to believe a product is going to work, they are less likely to purchase the product, leading to missed sales opportunities.


Reduced revenue affects your brand's profitability and growth potential. In a competitive market, missed sales opportunities can be capitalized upon by rival brands with more credible claims.

5. Negative Publicity

Unfounded claims often attract negative publicity. News outlets and social media platforms may pick up on the controversy, amplifying your brand's negative image. This has become more common following the FTC crackdown on unfounded claims, as it is public information which brands receive warnings about their claims.


Negative publicity can become a long-lasting stain on your brand's reputation, with potential customers associating it with dishonesty and deception.

6. Consumer Health and Safety Concerns

In some cases, unfounded product claims can pose health and wellness risks. If consumers rely on a product's claims for health benefits that are not delivered, it can lead to worsened symptoms and decreased daily quality of life.


Beyond the legal and reputational consequences, harming consumers' health can lead to lawsuits and, more importantly, ethical concerns that can irreparably damage your brand's image. Besides this, consumers may be harmed by your unfounded product claims.

Wrapping Up

In the world of consumer brands, trust and credibility are invaluable assets. Unsupported or misleading product claims can have severe consequences, ranging from damaged brand reputation and legal troubles to lost revenue and consumer trust. It is paramount for brands to prioritize accuracy, transparency, and ethics in their marketing efforts. Collaborating with reputable Contract Research Organizations (CROs) to substantiate product claims with rigorous scientific evidence is a proactive step toward building trust and safeguarding your brand's future. In a world where consumers demand authenticity and transparency, honesty truly is the best policy, not only for ethical reasons but also for long-term business success.

Want to create your own product claims?

Citruslabs provides a simple and affordable way to prove that your products actually work. At Citruslabs, we design a clinical trial that is right for you and your budget, so you can start sharing research-backed product claims without spending a fortune. We offer the cohesive planning and management required to conduct successful clinical trials, from start to finish. Ready to get started? Let's talk! You can contact us here.


bottom of page